Blog

For companies and inventors, securing a patent is often a critical step in protecting their intellectual property and gaining a competitive edge in the marketplace. However, obtaining a patent is only half the battle—enforcing that patent when others infringe upon it can lead to the complex and often lengthy process of patent litigation.

Patent litigation can be daunting, especially for those unfamiliar with the legal landscape. However, understanding the steps involved and being well-prepared can make a significant difference in the outcome. Whether you are the plaintiff (the patent holder) or the defendant (the accused infringer), knowing what to expect in a patent lawsuit will help you navigate the process with confidence.

This guide provides an overview of the key phases of patent litigation, common challenges, and strategies for preparing for this high-stakes legal battle.

When Does Patent Litigation Occur?
Patent litigation arises when a patent holder (the plaintiff) believes that another party (the defendant) is infringing on their patent rights. Patent infringement occurs when someone makes, uses, sells, or imports a patented invention without permission from the patent holder. This can happen in several forms:

1. Direct Infringement: When an entity uses or sells the patented invention without authorization.
2. Indirect Infringement: When a party contributes to or induces another party to infringe on a patent.
3. Willful Infringement: When an entity knowingly infringes on a patent with disregard for the patent holder’s rights. This can result in enhanced damages.

Patent litigation can be initiated by the patent owner to stop the infringement and recover damages. Alternatively, an accused party may preemptively file a lawsuit, known as a declaratory judgment action, to seek a court ruling that they are not infringing on the patent.

What to Expect During the Patent Litigation Process
Patent litigation follows a structured process, and understanding the key stages of this process will help you anticipate what lies ahead.

1. Pre-Litigation Investigation

Before filing a lawsuit, the patent holder typically conducts a thorough investigation to confirm the suspected infringement. This investigation includes:

• Patent Portfolio Review: Ensuring the patent in question is valid and enforceable.
• Infringement Analysis: Comparing the defendant’s product or service with the patent claims to determine if infringement has occurred.
• Market and Competitor Research: Assessing the impact of the infringement on the market and the plaintiff’s business.

Once the patent holder confirms that infringement has occurred, they may issue a cease and desist letter to the accused infringer, demanding that they stop the infringing activity. In some cases, this may lead to a settlement without litigation.

2. Filing the Lawsuit

If negotiations fail, the patent holder may file a formal complaint in federal court, initiating the patent litigation process. The complaint outlines the patent in question, the alleged infringement, and the damages being sought. The defendant will then have the opportunity to respond to the complaint, either admitting or denying the allegations.

In many cases, the defendant may file counterclaims, such as asserting that the patent is invalid or unenforceable. This can significantly complicate the litigation process, as the court must then address not only the infringement claim but also the validity of the patent.

3. Discovery Phase

The discovery phase is a critical part of patent litigation, during which both parties gather evidence to support their claims and defenses. This process can be time-consuming and costly, as it often involves:

• Document Production: Both sides exchange relevant documents, such as design plans, technical specifications, and communications.
• Interrogatories: Written questions that each party must answer under oath.
• Depositions: In-person interviews conducted under oath, during which witnesses (including inventors, company executives, and technical experts) provide testimony.
• Expert Testimony: Expert witnesses may be called upon to provide specialized knowledge regarding the patent, the technology in question, or the economic impact of the infringement.

Discovery is often the longest and most complex part of patent litigation, as it sets the foundation for the arguments that will be made at trial.

4. Markman Hearing (Claim Construction)

One of the most important steps in a patent lawsuit is the Markman hearing, also known as a claim construction hearing. In this hearing, the judge determines the meaning and scope of the patent’s claims—the specific aspects of the invention that are protected by the patent. The outcome of the Markman hearing can have a significant impact on the case, as it defines what the patent covers and whether the defendant’s product or service infringes upon it.

Both sides will present arguments regarding how the patent claims should be interpreted. After considering the evidence, the judge will issue a ruling, which will guide the remainder of the litigation process.

5. Settlement Discussions

Many patent lawsuits are settled before they reach trial. Once both sides have gathered enough evidence and the patent claims have been construed, the parties may engage in settlement discussions. Settlement can be an attractive option, as it allows both sides to avoid the costs and risks associated with a trial.

Settlements may involve the defendant agreeing to stop the infringing activity, paying a licensing fee or damages to the patent holder, or entering into a cross-licensing agreement.

6. Trial

If the case does not settle, it will proceed to trial. Patent trials are typically held in federal court, and they may be decided by either a judge or a jury. Both sides will present their arguments, introduce evidence, and call witnesses, including technical and economic experts. The trial will focus on key issues such as:

• Infringement: Whether the defendant’s product or service infringes on the patent claims.
• Validity: Whether the patent is valid and enforceable, or if it should be invalidated due to prior art, obviousness, or other factors.
• Damages: If infringement is proven, the court will determine the amount of damages owed to the patent holder.

Patent trials can be complex, as they often involve technical details and expert testimony. After the trial, the judge or jury will issue a ruling, which may include an injunction to stop the infringing activity and an award of damages.

7. Post-Trial Motions and Appeals

Even after the trial, the litigation process may not be over. Both parties may file post-trial motions, such as requests to modify the judgment or for a new trial. Additionally, the losing party may choose to appeal the decision to a higher court, which can prolong the resolution of the case.

Damages in Patent Litigation
If the patent holder prevails in a patent lawsuit, they may be entitled to monetary damages. Patent damages are typically calculated based on:

1. Lost Profits: Compensation for the sales the patent holder lost due to the infringement.
2. Reasonable Royalties: Payment based on the royalties the defendant would have paid if they had legally licensed the patent.
3. Enhanced Damages: In cases of willful infringement, the court may award enhanced damages, up to three times the amount of actual damages.

In some cases, the court may also issue an injunction, requiring the defendant to stop producing, using, or selling the infringing product or service.

How to Prepare for Patent Litigation
Whether you are the patent holder or the accused infringer, preparing for patent litigation is essential to achieving a successful outcome. Here are some key steps to help you prepare:

1. Work with Experienced Patent Counsel

Patent litigation is highly specialized, and it’s important to work with attorneys who have experience in both patent law and litigation. Your legal team should be able to help you navigate the complexities of the case, develop a winning strategy, and manage the technical and legal challenges that arise during the process.

2. Understand Your Patent

For patent holders, it’s essential to have a deep understanding of the patent in question, including its claims, scope, and potential weaknesses. Conduct a thorough review of the patent portfolio and be prepared to explain how the defendant’s product or service infringes on your patent.

For defendants, it’s equally important to analyze the patent and identify any grounds for challenging its validity or contesting the infringement claims.

3. Gather and Preserve Evidence

Gather all relevant documents, communications, and technical materials related to the patent and the alleged infringement. Preserving this evidence is crucial, as it will play a key role in the discovery process and at trial. Be sure to keep detailed records of product designs, development processes, and any prior art that may be relevant to the case.

4. Consider Settlement Options

Given the costs and risks associated with patent litigation, it’s important to consider settlement options early in the process. Be open to negotiation and explore potential licensing agreements, cross-licenses, or other forms of dispute resolution that can help you avoid a lengthy trial.

Conclusion: Navigating the Complexities of Patent Litigation
Patent litigation can be a challenging and high-stakes process, but with proper preparation and experienced legal counsel, you can successfully protect your intellectual property or defend against infringement claims. Understanding the key phases of patent litigation, the potential risks and rewards, and the importance of a solid legal strategy will help you navigate the process with confidence.

At Lerner Greenberg Stemer, we specialize in patent litigation and are dedicated to helping clients protect their valuable intellectual property rights. Whether you are pursuing a patent infringement claim or defending against one, our team of skilled patent attorneys is here to guide you every step of the way.

Need Assistance with Patent Litigation? Contact Us Today
If you’re facing patent litigation or need to enforce your patent rights, reach out to our experienced legal team for a consultation. Let us help you achieve the best possible outcome in your case.

Your innovation deserves the strongest protection—trust experience. Trust results.